Newcastle, KwaZulu-Natal — Newcastle Local Municipality has come under intensified scrutiny following explosive allegations raised during a KwaZulu-Natal Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA) engagement on 28 January, where municipalities were briefed on the 2023/24 local government audit outcomes.
During the session, Newcastle Municipality was singled out for what participants described as “queen spending”, with allegations that the municipality spent R28 million on VIP toilet hire and a staggering R65 million on plant hire. The expenditure figures, presented in the context of weak audit outcomes, immediately raised concerns about procurement controls, value for money and potential conflicts of interest.
Of particular concern were allegations that some of the plant and heavy machinery hired by the municipality allegedly belong to Mayor Xolani Dube. It was further claimed that trucks linked to the mayor were seen operating on municipal projects, including re-graveling work currently under way in Ward 12.
If substantiated, such arrangements could constitute a serious breach of municipal ethics and supply chain regulations, which prohibit public office-bearers from benefiting directly or indirectly from municipal contracts. However, no ownership documentation or procurement records were publicly produced at the engagement, and the claims remain allegations pending verification.
The allegations extend beyond possible conflicts of interest to process failures. Community representatives and participants at the engagement alleged that no public participation process took place prior to the awarding of the disputed contracts , a requirement under the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA) and municipal governance frameworks. The lack of visible consultation has fuelled suspicions that procurement decisions may have been rushed, improperly approved, or shielded from public scrutiny.
Further compounding the controversy were allegations that the municipality spent R14 million on a road project covering an extremely short distance, prompting questions about how project costs were calculated and approved.
Participants reportedly questioned whether such spending reflects prudent financial management, particularly in a municipality grappling with persistent service-delivery backlogs, aging infrastructure and frequent community complaints.
The allegations surfaced during discussions on audit outcomes — a forum intended to strengthen accountability and address governance weaknesses. Observers say the Newcastle case illustrates the very issues highlighted by the Auditor-General year after year: weak oversight, poor consequence management and opaque procurement practices.
Civil society organisations and opposition figures have since called for provincial intervention and a forensic investigation into the municipality’s supply chain processes, including full disclosure of suppliers, contract values and beneficiary interests.
As of publication, Newcastle Municipality has not issued a detailed response to the specific allegations raised at the COGTA engagement. While Mayor Xolani Dube has previously defended the municipality’s compliance with procurement legislation, no formal clarification has been provided regarding the R28 million VIP toilet hire, the R65 million plant hire, or the alleged involvement of mayor-linked equipment in municipal projects.
Until procurement records are made public or investigations conclude, the allegations remain unresolved. However, analysts warn that the absence of swift, transparent responses risks further eroding public trust in a municipality already under pressure to demonstrate clean governance and fiscal discipline.
What are your thoughts on this article? Drop a comment, we would love to hear from you!
The Supply Chain MFC act is been breached to ground on all Newcastle tenders and contracts, some even with Vacant land sites with Gross maladminstion within the Political and Public individuals. If NEWCASTLE citizens only unite and stand up , Many will loose their positions Immediately, especially in the Politians in Colision partners in ward Councilor interference.
Investigations needed asap .Adhoc circus exists in all state institutions.
Only a forensic audit would reveal the extent of the rot and corruption at the Newcastle Municipality.
The Municipal Public Accounts Committee has failed in its execution of its duty.
Now we know why we owe Eskom over R700m, Uthukela Water over R306m, SARS, Employee Benefits, Creditors etc. so technically the municipality is bankrupt.
Service delivery is almost non existent.
The credibility of the office of AGSA is highly compromised as they seem to be Captured as well
Unqualified Audit opinion is not consistent with these findings